Story of my Neighbor Cuckolding Me!

By: Me & Amy

Hello,

After our first year of dating, I confessed my cuckold fetish to my girlfriend Amy. To my surprise and delight, she was not scared by the idea of hooking up with other men and was generally supportive of trying it in the future. We still lived in our small hometown though and she was afraid that news would get around quickly if she did anything too scandalous. So despite her willingness, my potential future as a cuckold was temporarily on hold.

Amy had always been upfront with me about her sexual fetishes as well. While she loved me and everything about our day to day relationship, sexually she had always been turned on by guys who were assholes. Her dating history was littered with jerks who treated her like shit. She hated everything about them except the way they fucked her. She was naturally submissive and got turned on by guys objectifying and dominating her. I was never physically or emotionally capable of giving her those experiences.

A few months later, I accepted a job offer in another state. Both Amy and I were excited to move somewhere new. I, of course, was also excited about the possibility of her finally making me a cuckold. We found a house in a suburban area that was relatively affordable and moved in immediately.

Amy didn't have a job in the new town and spent most of her day organizing the house and working out while I was at work. She loves to jog and would typically jog for at least two or three miles every day. It was during these jogs that she met our neighbor Jeremy. He is in his fifties, a bit overweight, and retired. The first time they met, Amy had just stopped her jog and was catching her breath. Jeremy called out to her from his front porch and asked if she was new to the area. Amy confirmed that she was and pointed to our house next door. Jeremy then exclaimed that she was his new neighbor and Amy laughed and said yes. They exchanged names and Amy then politely excused herself to go home.

A couple days later, Amy met some other women in the neighborhood during her jog. They asked where she lived and she described our house. One of the women then asked if that was the house next to Jeremy. Amy confirmed that it was and said that she actually just met Jeremy. The woman was horrified and said that Jeremy was known for sitting on his front porch all day and cat calling women as they walked by. They told her to avoid Jeremy if possible and she thanked them for their advice.

As Amy got home and jogged passed Jeremy's house, he was on his front porch. It was hot out and she was just wearing a sport bra and small running shorts. Jeremy called out to her and Amy just waived with a smile as she continued. As she passed his house, Jeremy yelled that he loved watching her from behind. Amy didn't respond and went straight into our house.

Later that night, Amy told me about Jeremy and what the other women had said. I didn't know how quite to respond. I had met Jeremy just briefly when we first moved in but hadn't seen him since. I asked Amy how she felt and she just responded that she wasn't going to stop jogging just cause our neighbor was a creep.

A couple days later, Amy encountered Jeremy on her way home from jogging again. He was in his front yard and beckoned her to stop and talk. Amy said high and Jeremy looked her sweaty body up and down before suggesting that they exchange phone numbers in case there was ever any issue between our houses. A bit reluctantly, Amy gave Jeremy her phone number which he immediately recorded in his phone. He then texted Amy so she had his number as well.

When she got into the home, Amy check her phone and saw Jeremy's text. It said "Thanks for your number hot stuff. You can put my number in your phone as 'daddy'. That's how most girls your age refer to me anyways :)".

Amy was infuriated by Jeremy's message but also simultaneously a bit turned on. She had never felt this way before for an older man but his boldness definitely got on her nerves, both in a bad way and in a good way. It was sunny out and Amy decided that she'd go lay down in the backyard and sun tan for a bit to cool her temper. One of the highlights of our house was that the backyard felt very private and there were no two story houses near us that could look in over our fence.

Amy laid out a towel on the grass and took off her sports bra and shorts. She was now topless and just wearing a thong. She laid face down and tried to rest but couldn't get Jeremy's audacity out of her head. She got very worked up thinking about how she'd respond to him next time they spoke. After ten minutes, Amy flipped over exposing her boobs to the sun. As she continued thinking about Jeremy, she couldn't help herself and reached down to rub her pussy and relieve the tension. And just a couple minutes later, she convulsed and orgasmed strongly.

Coming to her senses, Amy got up and came back into the house. While she was in the shower, she received another text from Jeremy. To her horror, the message had an image of Amy topless and rubbing herself in our backyard. It was taken from Jeremy's roof. Jeremy said he was just cleaning the gutters when he noticed her. And he offered his help if she was feeling sexually frustrated. Amy was mortified. She quickly got dressed and walked over to Jeremy's house. She knocked loudly on the door which Jeremy opened with a giant smile on his face. Amy told him to delete that picture immediately off his phone. Jeremy laughed and said he'd delete it but asked what he'd get in return. Amy said nothing and told him again to just delete it. Jeremy then offered to delete it if she flashed him his boobs. Amy told Jeremy that he had just seen her boobs but Jeremy complained that she was so far away that he didn't get a very good look. He said it was a fair trade... she'd flash him her boobs up close and he'd delete the photos and videos he took. Amy was surprised to hear of the additional photos and videos and agreed to flash her boobs in exchange for Jeremy deleting them.

Jeremy led Amy into his house and closed the door. They stood just a few feet across for each other in the entry way. Amy then pulled up the bottom of her shirt and quickly flashed her boobs for just half a second to Jeremy. He said she'd have to do it longer than that. He showed her his phone that had nearly a dozen photos and videos of her. Amy was exasperated and said she'd show her boobs for ten seconds and that was it. Jeremy nodded in agreement and Amy pulled up her shirt again. Amy felt completely humiliated as Jeremy stared at her boobs but she was getting turned on again as well. Jeremy called her a 'good girl' and said she could come over to his house any time she wanted. Amy sarcastically said that she bet Jeremy would like that. Jeremy then retorted that maybe she would like it and she could 'spend more time with her daddy'. It had probably been closer to fifteen seconds at this point and Amy pulled her shirt back down. Jeremy then handed her his phone and she personally deleted all the photos and videos of herself. She then went into his messages app and deleted the photo there as well. As she did though, she noticed that Jeremy had her name as 'slut next door' in his phone. She gave his phone back to them and then stormed out as Jeremy said 'come back to daddy anytime you want'.

When I got home, Amy told me everything that had happened and I could barely believe it. I asked how she felt and she complained that he was still stuck in her head hours later. She asked if I was turned on and I admitted that I was a bit. I was jealous and angry and turned on all at the same time. Amy said she felt conflicted as well.

The next day after I left, Amy texted Jeremy and told him that she wasn't a slut and asked him to change her name to 'Amy' in his phone. Jeremy responded and said he would change her name back if she changed his name to 'Daddy' in her phone and referred to him exclusively as 'Daddy' going forward. Amy replied quickly and told him no way.

Infuriated again, Amy decided to go on a jog to clear her mind. Picking out her clothes though, she found herself considering what Jeremy might think about what she wore. Should she dress conservatively in a long shirt and pants? Or should she wear her skimpiest sports bra and shorts? Amy worried that either decision would send a message to Jeremy that he was affecting her. It was very hot out so Amy reluctantly decided to wear one of her skimpier outfits so she could at least be comfortable as she jogged.

Amy jogged for over an hour while periodically thinking about Jeremy and imaging how she should respond to him next time they met. As she got back close to home, she noticed she was getting butterflies in her stomach just in anticipation of the chance that she might see him. And when she got to our block, she saw Jeremy on his front porch waiting for her. She stopped in front of his house and Jeremy asked if she wanted to show off for him again. Amy said no and requested that she change her name in his phone again. Jeremy asked why and she exclaimed that she wasn't a 'slut'. He responded saying that it was a matter of opinion but she could come in if she wanted to change his mind. He then walked into his house but left the front door open.

Determined to get what she wanted, Amy followed and went into his house. She closed the door behind herself and found Jeremy sitting on a chair in the next room. Jeremy invited her to join him. She walked over and then sat on a chair across from him. She felt exposed in her skimpy running outfit and instantly regretted her decision to wear it.

After she sat down, Jeremy calmly said he'd be happy to change her name in his phone. Amy asked what the catch was. Jeremy grinned and asked he why there had to be catch. After a few seconds, he then asked Amy if she wanted there to be a catch. Amy scowled and said no. Jeremy then said "I'll tell you what... I'll change your name in my phone if you sit on my lap and call me daddy just once." Amy immediately said no and acted disgusted. Jeremy responded and said she'd always be his 'slut next door' in his phone then. Amy felt powerless. She thought it over and eventually conceded to Jeremy. But she said she needed to see him change her name in his phone first and then she'd sit on his lap. Jeremy agreed and showed her his phone as proof after the change. In accordance with their agreement, Amy then stood up and walked in front of Jeremy. He pulled her forward and she fell awkwardly onto him with her legs straddling the chair and his lap. Amy complained that this wasn't the agreement. She could feel his dick through his pants and against her crotch. It felt huge and increasingly hard which made Amy flustered. Amy asked Jeremy what else she needed to do. Jeremy told her to call him 'daddy'. Amy looked him in the eyes and meekly said 'daddy'. Jeremy then scolded her and said she needed to really say it like she meant it. If not, he'd change her name back to 'slut' in his phone. Amy responded saying "please daddy" louder this time. Jeremy laughed and said "that's a good girl". He let her stand up and she had a noticeable wet spot on her crotch. It was partly sweat from jogging and also partly her arousal of being pressed against his cock.

Jeremy noticed the wetness on her shorts and asked her if she enjoyed sitting on his lap. Amy said no while embarrassingly trying to cover herself. Jeremy asked if she liked feeling his dick. Amy said no again but more softly this time. He then told Amy that he'd show her his dick if she asked nicely. Amy didn't respond but also made no effort to leave. She stood there for several seconds before eventually saying ok. Jeremy then repeated that she had to ask nicely if she really wanted to see it.... and added that she should get on her knees and ask. Amy hated that she was doing this but her horniest took over. She sat down on her knees in front of Jeremy, looked up at him, and said "please daddy, show me your cock". Jeremy responded saying "good girl" as he unbuckled his pants in front of her face. He then pushed his pants and boxers down and his cock sprang out in front of her face. Amy looked at it dumbfounded. It was the biggest cock she had ever seen. Jeremy asked if she liked it and she said yes. He asked if she had ever seen a cock as big as his before and she said no. Jeremy said it wasn't even fully hard yet and told her to take off her top and show him her pretty little titties again. Almost mindlessly, Amy obeyed and slipped her sports bra off, revealing her boobs to him once again. Jeremy then started to jerk his cock and Amy watched it grow even more in front of her face.

Eventually, Amy came to her senses and stood up. She told Jeremy that everything had gone too far and that she had a boyfriend. She then put her sports bra back on and darted out his front door. When she got into our house, she went immediately into the shower and started to masturbate to the image of Jeremy's dick that was engraved in her brain now. When I got home, she gave me a brief overview of what had happened. She was worried I would be mad but I said I supported everything she did and reminded her that I loved her no matter what she chose to do with him. Amy was happy for my support but worried that she wouldn't be able to stop once she gave him into him. As we continued discussing what had happened, Amy received a text from Jeremy. He said that his cock was still hard thinking about her tits and asked her to send a photo for him to jerk off to if she was too afraid to do it in person. Amy asked me what she should do and I just told her to keep going since she had already gone this far.

Amy took the next thirty minutes trying to pose for a sexy photo for Jeremy. Eventually she found an angle she liked in front of the bathroom mirror that could show both her front and back. Then rummaging through her underwear drawer, she picked out a silky red thong that I had bought her for Valentine's Day. She slipped on the thong and took dozens of photos of herself until she found one that she liked enough to share with Jeremy. She then sent gulped and hit send on her send on her phone. She knew sending him the picture was the equivalent of diving into the deep end of whatever game they were playing. A couple minutes later, Jeremy sent back a screenshot of her contact on his phone that included the topless picture she had just sent as her face card and renamed her again as 'slut next door'.

A couple days later, I had to go on a business trip and would be leaving Amy alone for a few days. Though we didn't discuss it directly, we both knew that something would inevitably happen between her and Jeremy over that time frame. As I packed up my car in the driveway to go to the airport, I tried to make it obvious that I was leaving in case Jeremy might be watching. Amy even ran out and kissed me in the driveway and then waived me goodbye as I drove away.

After I left, Amy immediately went on a jog while wearing her skimpiest sports bra and tights. Eager to see Jeremy again, she only jogged a few miles before returning home. When she returned though, he wasn't on his porch like normal. Amy was sad at first and then worked up the courage to go up to his front door and knock. Jeremy opened the door for her and she walked in immediately. He asked her what she wanted and she paused momentarily before taking off her sports bra, getting on her knees, and saying "please daddy can you show me your cock again". Jeremy laughed and asked if she was a slut or not. She replied "yes daddy I'm a slut". Jeremy then told her to take off her bottoms for him. She stood up and immediately pushed them down her legs. She was now standing completely naked in front of Jeremy.

Jeremy then led Amy into his living room and sat on his chair. He pulled her down so she was once again facing him while strangling his crotch. Amy put her arms around his shoulders and they started kissing very passionately. As they did, Jeremy groped her boobs and ass and touched almost every inch of her body. Eventually Amy pulled back from the kiss and brought her chest up to his mouth. Jeremy immediately started sucking her nipples as she moaned in pleasure. Then Amy got up and returned to her position on her knees in front of him. Jeremy pushed his pants down as Amy helped until his cock was released once again in front of her face. Amy stared at it and started rubbing her pussy. Jeremy then stood up and started jerking his cock just inches from her mouth. Amy instinctively leaned forward and let Jeremy rub and hit his cock against her face until she eventually took it into her mouth and started sucking it. Despite being skilled at giving oral, Amy later admitted that his cock was just too big and she could barely even get her mouth around it.

As the struggled to suck his cock, Amy continued to rub herself and was close to cumming. Jeremy sensed her impending orgasm and told her she had to request permission to cum. Amy played along and said "please daddy, can I cum?" but Jeremy said no. This kept Amy on the edge and she was nearly begging to cum seconds later. "Please daddy... I need to cum!". Jeremy told her again to wait as he took his cock out of her mouth and jerked it off directly in front of her face. Amy was moaning and struggling to prevent her impending orgasm for as long as possible. Jeremy then said they would cum at the same time and started counting down. Amy paced herself to his countdown and opened her mouth to receive his seed. As he got to one, Jeremy started squirting stream after stream of cum across her mouth, face, hair, chest, and legs. Amy orgasmed uncontrollably as she got completely covered nearly from head to toe. After they both stopped cumming, Jeremy got his phone and pointed it towards Amy. He took several photos of her as she sat there covered in cum while calling her a 'good slut'. He then asked Amy if she was gonna thank him and Amy said "Thank you daddy for your cum". Amy then got up and grabbed her clothes. Jeremy didn't offer her anything to clean off and told her to just get dressed and get out. She slipped her shorts and sports bra on and Jeremy pushed her out. She then jogged quickly back to our home to make sure no one saw her.

Back home, Amy masturbated again in the bathroom while tasting the remnants of Jeremy's cum from different parts of her body. After she came twice more, she took a shower to clean herself off and then called me to tell me everything that happened. I was thrilled to hear her recount every detail and amazed by how slutty she behaved for him.

A couple days later, Amy walked over to Jeremy's house and knocked on his door again. She did her makeup and wore a dress without any bra or panties on underneath. Jeremy let her in and said she looked more like a slut each time she came over. Amy took this as a compliment now and smiled for him. He led her to his bedroom which she had never seen before. Once inside, Jeremy pulled her dress off and leaned her down against the edge of his bed. She pulled her legs up and held them spread eagle for him. He then dropped his pants and positioned his cock over her lower torso. It extended from her pussy at its base to past her belly button at the tip. Amy looked down at it and said "please daddy I need your dick inside me". Jeremy then put his dick in front of her pussy and proceeded to slowly insert it inch by inch. Amy squealed at it was easily the biggest thing that ever had been inside of her. He kept going in a bit farther and then backing out for several minutes until finally his cock was fully inside her. Now that she had felt his full size, he started to fuck her properly. Amy was moaning loudly as the initial pain gave way to intense pleasure. As he continued to pound her, he leaned forward and she put her legs around his back and arms around his shoulders.

They kissed briefly before Jeremy picked up the pace and started to send Amy over the edge. Remembering his rule, she asked permission to cum and Jeremy told her yes immediately this time. And less than a minute later, she requested permission again which Jeremy granted. Jeremy then leaned back up but kept his hands on her boobs... massaging them and occasionally pinching her nipples which Amy loved. He slowed his pace and Amy started rubbing her clit for him. Soon she requested another orgasm but Jeremy said no this time. He said they were going to cum at the same time again. Amy just replied "yes daddy" as he started counting down from five. Amy could now feel his cock tensing up inside of her and she started to cum uncontrollably before Jeremy got to two. As she screamed in pleasure, he erupted inside of her and filled her pussy to the brim with his cum. They both regained composure and Amy let out another yelp as Jeremy slipped out of her and his cum started spilling out of her pussy as well. Jeremy picked up his phone and took pictures of Amy again covered in his cum. Amy was barely able to walk and fell down to her knees on the side of the bed. Jeremy then fed her his cock and had her swallow any remaining cum coming out of him. Eventually he pulled Amy up and she slipped her dress back on. He ushered her out of his house as his cum continued to stream down her legs. Amy then stumbled over to our house just as I arrived home from my business trip.

Inside the house together, Amy told me everything that had happened and I watched in amazement as his cum continued to pour out of her. Amy said she was too tired to even give me a handjob but she let me jerk off as I watched her in the shower. I came quickly as Amy watched. She then laughed and congratulated me on finally becoming a cuckold.

Me & Amy - mahmiss@tutanota.com

Other Couples' Blog Submissions:
My First Time as a Bull
Wife was Fucked Three Times
Felt like a Hot Poker went into my Stomach

...

BACK TO THE BLOG

Forum ||  Cuckold Stories ||  Cuck Couples ||  Cuckold Blog ||  Cuckold Chat || 
Cuckold Couple ||  Sitting on a Cock ||  Meet MILFs ||  Classifieds ||  Personals ||  Hotwife Emily ||  Fuck My Wife ||  She's Horny ||  Shari and Mark ||  Dare Party ||  Women who will Cuckold You ||  Mistress Hottie ||